Such interviews or questionnaires can be designed using usual social scientific methods. In recent years there is also an increasing use of internet surveys.
Newspaper data analysis A great deal of crowd research relies on the analysis of media, such as newspaper and electronic reports. The disadvantages of this method refer to the fact that it may contain lopsided views and descriptions.
Their findings show that only 10 percent of the registered events were actually reported and most of the demonstrations have a participation of less than 25 persons, while the likelihood of media coverage was connected with the size of the event.
Conversely, Retzlaff provides an analysis of a overwhelmingly positive media coverage during the World Cup in Germany with regard to the construction of concept of collective German patriotism.
The issue of media influence is also discussed in the empirical papers Paper 2, 3, 4 of this thesis. Seidler, Meyer and Gillivray developed a set of techniques for data gathering among stationary crowds.
Drury and Stott advocate the use of direct, on-the-spot observational strategies for the research of crowd events.
They argue that crowd events are characteristically intergroup encounters, in which there is a mutual influence of the participating parties.
Therefore, in order to understand crowd psychology i. In practical terms, Drury and Stott suggest that the researcher joins with one group, basically becoming an ingroup member and 22 thereby opposing the outgroup.
Advantages are seen in three aspects: Firstly, ingroup members will far more likely be open for interviews and talk about their views and perceptions of a specific situation and their relations to outgroup members and they are more willing to share internal documents and knowledge.
However, taking sides may also mean constrained if not impossible access to the outgroup. Secondly, the quality of data is improved. The final point concerns the data analysis and the question if it is possible to maintain a distance to accounts of in-group participants within a framework of partisan research.
Structured observations Although crowd research activities are to a great deal based on ethnography, some methods have been developed for systematically observing and recording collective action, that transfer the happenings during a crowd event into quantifiable data and thus allow for a statistical comparison of different events.
Schweingruber and McPhail aimed to design a method that records the extent and variation of crowd behaviour, is flexible enough to be used for different types of gatherings and research questions, and is easy to use so that observers can easily be instructed.
The development of the method went along with a conceptual understanding of crowds. The actual data recording is carried out by multiple observers, most of which are undergraduate students that are distributed among the crowd.
Prior to the actual event the observers are given written documentation and a training session that includes information on the specific event and the procedures involved in this method.
During the event the observers fill in a code sheet, recording what is being done collective action can be allocated to 40 different forms and by whom.
Here, six categories are provided: As violence involves at least an actor and a target, Adang argues that violent behaviour cannot be understood without considering the interaction between these two parties.
This focus on interaction can be seen as the main difference of this approach to that of Schweingruber and McPhail Variables were drawn from preliminary analyses of a number of real-life situations and video material as well as a literature review on crowd events.
They further had to be easily observable so that they could also be determined by the participants themselves and they had to bear an impact on the situation, for example: Similar to the procedure of Schweingruber and McPhail, the observers receive a comprehensive training, including lectures on the theoretical background, the observation protocol, observation techniques and observation exercises.
The observations at football games cover the time in which most of the fans were present at the venue and in the city centre, generally starting several hours before kick-off and were finished some hours after the game.
The observers were instructed to choose areas where large groups of fans gather, for example at the central station, at squares in the city centre and around the stadia.
Every fifteen minutes a sample is taken on the number and kind of persons e. Police intervention is defined as dispersal, stopping or arrests and it is noted if police had made use of force.
Observers also take notes on their impressions and observations that they made in-between sample time.
The systematic observations allow to relate different variables to the number of incidents and to compare results of different events.
Alternative developments of crowd research Impacts of technical development on crowd observations New technological developments and the increased use of internet facilities provide a wide range of data collection around crowd events aside of any planned scientific research design.
Levine ; Economist, took advantage of the multiple display of the CCTV camera surveillance system in Britain to explore the factors that make the presence of bystanders successful or unsuccessful.
The group had gained permission to use the video footage of incidents at public spaces in the night-time-economy that had been recorded within 25 one year between January and February in British towns and cities.
In doing so they were able to study group behaviour in a natural setting that could previously not be tested for either practical or ethical reasons.
The videos had no sound and the persons could not be recognised. Incidents were chosen with regard to certain criteria, such as length of the incident and group size.
A coding scheme was developed that covered the themes of status e. The results suggest that groups spontaneously try to regulate the behaviour of ingroup members and that the prevention of violence increases with group size.
It is argued that such reports would distort and misinterpret the actual happenings and serve as a base for restrictions of liberal human rights and justifications thereof.
In Germany such observations are carried out since the protests against the nuclear plant in Brokdorf Steven, Similar processes can be observed in the context of football: As a reaction to what they felt as illegitimate police conduct some groups of football fans have undertaken own measures for evaluating an event.
The observation activities are not announced and will only be published successive to the respective game. The groups are using field observational methods carried out contemporaneously.
Observations focus on the behaviour of mainly police forces but also on other security staff with football fans.
The observation groups are requested to focus on questions such as: Has the policing been reasonable and proportional in all aspects?
Was the behaviour respectful, did the officers introduce themselves, were fans informally addressed on a first name basis. Did officers act socially sensibly with regard to youngsters?
Were there any unreasonable harassments observable? The reports are published on the internet. Peer review teams An alternative form of evaluating crowd events has lately gained increased interest.
The basic idea of this approach is to bring together public order scientists and police practitioners in the observation of an event. Evaluation of a crowd events is not carried out by some ivory tower inhabitants far detached from real life as 26 some police practitioners may see academics , but by colleagues from other forces that are dealing with similar problems in their own work.
From to a pilot study involving 13 evaluations was carried out on request of the EU Police Cooperation Working Party. The peer reviews are now part of EU training program for police commanders.
When a peer review is requested, the hosting force is asked to name of number of evaluation points. It is these points that the subsequent evaluation plan is then designed around.
A team of about 5 police commanders is composed and is accompanied by academic staff. A peer review takes three days. On Day 1 the team arrives at the site, familiarises with the infrastructure, makes first contacts with the police forces and other parties that are relevant with regard to the respective event e.
On the basis of the evaluation points the team then agrees on an evaluation plan. On Day 2, the day of the event the team conducts interviews and carries out contemporaneous observations prior, during and after the event.
Day 3 is used for writing up the first draft of the evaluation report, when team members discuss their observations in relation to the respective evaluation points.
The report will be worked out by the academic member of the team and send to the members for a final check up before it is delivered to the requesting force.
The value of this method has different aspects. An important factor lies in the confidentiality of the evaluation and the final report will be the ownership of the requesting force.
The reviewers themselves gained concrete new ideas from their observations and during the discussions with their colleagues. They also valued the fact that they were able to look at a police operation from the outside.
The cooperation of practitioners and scientists helps to break up barriers and to gain more understanding. Many reviewers experienced it was difficult to first observe, and then make conclusions: Up to date theses evaluations have been carried out mainly in the context of football.
Some forces have begun to introduce national peer reviews, some are planning to use peer reviews for the evaluation of 27 the policing of demonstrations.
Along with other models the ESIM draws on interaction, more specifically it suggest that in order to understand the dynamics of a crowd event it is necessary to consider the relations and ongoing interactions between those groups that are present at a specific event.
The ESIM has been developed from - and was validated by a substantial number of studies of crowd events in violent and non-violent situations. Summarising its basic assumptions the ESIM explains both the escalation and the avoidance of collective conflict as a result of ongoing social relations.
Secondly, the ESIM explains the establishment and maintenance of non-violent norms as a result of legitimate group relations between crowd members and the police, avoiding an identity shift towards conflict.
It is proposed that legitimate group relations are connected with selfpolicing, marginalisation of violent crowd participants, and lack of support for attempts of provocation.
This approach has meanwhile been integrated in practical policing and into guidelines for the policing of football matches with an international dimension within the EU.
Despite this obvious practical relevance, the scientific analyses on crowd dynamics based on the ESIM have only focused on British in particular, English and Scottish crowds so that there were only few theoretical and empirical analyses of how such dynamics apply to crowds from other cultural backgrounds.
Methodical and methodological considerations The methods and analytical strategies of this thesis are determined by the assumptions of the model, so that the respective parties involved and their mutual interaction had to be 29 considered; these are described in more detail in the respective papers.
Furthermore, the research activities were sought to be carried out contemporaneously because the direct observation of - and the participation in a crowd event allows to focus on aspects that are relevant with regard to the theoretical model and it provides for the flexibility that is necessary within such a dynamic framework.
This approach further makes it possible to collect data on reactions and comments of persons that are immediately involved in or subjected by the event; in doing so it is possible to document how perceptions and behaviour relate to a possibly changing context.
Like Bar-Tal has pointed at the difficulties that are imminent in doing research around real life events, similar methodological issues concern this thesis.
The aim of this thesis is therefore not to provide a test of hypotheses. It rather seeks to provide an explorative study and it aims to contribute to the body of research that has up to now been carried out around the ESIM.
While, in a rigorous positivistic sense, this does not serve as a method of gaining new scientific insight, this research seeks to present additional material in order enhance plausibility of this model.
The results can further serve as a hypothesis generating procedure and a base for further research which may be broken down into testable studies.
Research questions and empirical studies Drawing on the lack of cross cultural research among ESIM studies, the research of this thesis focuses on the following research question: This main research question was broken into different sub-questions, each of which is presented within an individual research paper.
Paper 1 presents an incident involving German fans during the European Championships While Stott and colleagues , had provided analyses involving England fans this paper seeks to answer the question: Were the processes that the ESIM proposes are responsible for the absence of widespread disorder among England fans also evident among German fans attending the same tournament?
Studies including Paper 1 which explain the shift away from violence mainly refer to the policing that was carried out around the Euro It may be argued, however, that the success of Euro was singular, merely applying to that one event or the specific groups that were present in Portugal during the tournament.
Research was therefore carried out at Germany , focussing on the following questions: Do the relations and the effects that the ESIM suggests also apply in different contexts that may be formed by national or cultural features or by the understandings and philosophies of the police forces?
How do police tactics and deployments relate to the relations between different fan groups and between fans and the police? Paper 3 presents a case study involving Polish and German fans at the same day.
Specifically, the study examines the relation between the policing strategy and tactics and the behaviour and perception of Poland and Germany fans in contexts of risk and non-risk.
As prior to the tournament a substantial number of papers and other media had described Poland fans in a rather negative way, the paper further sought to answer the question: Was the negative image that was portrayed of the Poland fans before the tournament justified and did this have an impact on the relations between the fan groups and the fans and the police?
Paper 4 explores German fan identity at three different tournaments: In contrast to previous ESIM research, which describes social change as a result of conflictual group relations, this study examined social change within a peaceful context.
It examines the effects and dynamics of symmetric group relations and in doing so to provide an explanation of why German fans in and subsequently in were empowered to live out their national identity and positive emotions but not so in ?
The actual research activities are presented as single paper publications in scientific journals. The papers are integrated in the following section.
Each paper is preceded by a foreword of the author. It reports on personal impressions and experiences that occurred during the research process and it highlights aspects of the research that seem relevant to this thesis but are not or only briefly mentioned in the actual research paper.
Funding by the ESRC had enabled a comprehensive research design using a variety of methods; most of which were carried out contemporaneously and data triangulation would then provide a rather comprehensive picture of the goings on.
Much of the data that came out of this program has meanwhile been published elsewhere; however, the focus group is English see Reicher et al.
In line with the other research activities the data collection should be carried out contemporaneously; using an ethnographic approach was seen as the most flexible and fruitful way to provide for a broad body of data.
This could then be triangulated with the data that was collected by other observers of the research team. The idea was for me to be with the fans to listen, speak and observe.
As it is the case with ethnographic research, access to and a kind of acceptance by the group being studied is vital. I believe that more than 25 years of being a football fan myself, has provided the necessary authenticity to get this access on the field, in this case in the fan zones, cafes, stadium, camping sites.
Personal contacts with the German fan project also helped to get access to some more internal information for example when some were arrested.
However, being interested in crowd-police interaction the research also concerned the role, perception and behaviour of the police. A delegation of German police spotters was present in Portugal, liaising with Portuguese colleagues with a focus on the German risk supporters.
Again, it was personal contacts that were made with the German home office and the German national football information point that facilitated 32 access to these bodies during the tournament.
Like with the fan group, acceptance and trust are vital to get access. So it was for example possible for me to make informal conversations around the gatherings of fans and to conduct semi-structured interviews with members of the German police delegation.
After all, we cannot usually predict when a riot will occur. And this was in fact the place where the incident happened that this paper reports on.
The incident indeed occurred around the most high risk game of the tournament Germany versus the Netherlands ; there had been tensions and expectations beforehand and there had been provocations that initiated violence.
In a way this was all well after the textbook. But, as it is outlined in the paper, low profile policing tactics of close surveillance, quick and targeted interventions and clear escalative and deescalative deployment prevented the situation from further escalation.
Five people were detained that night, but as no further German fans got arrested in the remaining part of the tournament though some did for ticket touting , this was indeed the biggest incident.
Ironically, this conflict did not occur on matchday but on the night before. So while we were prepared for multiple comprehensive data collection, the structured observations could not be used for this study, as they focused on the actual match day where there was no incident.
With regard to the ESI-model of crowd behaviour, this study has different implications: Secondly, it supports the model by providing support that similar processes were at place with German fans as they were with England fans in Portugal.
As incidents involving England fans occurred in Lisbon but the Germans were in Porto, there may be an effect of the specific policing in one city.
Finally, the study promotes the positive effect of combining research and practise, as it had been the close collaboration between police authorities and scientists that provided the base for the strategic approach that was carried out at the tournament, which has up to now been the most peaceful that has been carried out in Europe within the last 30 years.
Tag schuf Gott den 1. This paper provides an analysis of the social psychological processes among German football fans during the European Championships in Portugal in relation to the policing that was carried out by the Portuguese Security Police.
Data was collected drawing on qualitative observational methods. The analysis focuses on a violent incident between German and Dutch fans prior to the game between the Netherlands and Germany in Porto.
Findings suggest a connection between low profile policing and the support of non-violent group norms among the wider crowd and the disempowerment and marginalisation of confrontational groups.
The article concluded with a description about a group of German fans that peacefully and unhindered raised their banner amidst a Dutch crowd Klemm After the Dutch trauma in and the German trauma in a peak was reached when a Dutch and a German player were sent off for spitting and arguing at the World Cup in in Italy.
While the situation has somewhat calmed since and public disorder at Netherlands-Germany fixtures is more connected with 4 Germany beat the Netherlands at the WC finals in Germany; The Netherlands beat Germany at the Euro in Germany and subsequently won the tournament.
German police forces set bans to prevent known troublemakers from travelling and the Portuguese authorities assessed this game as the one posing the highest risk of the tournament.
However, it turned out very peaceful with multiple friendly encounters between the groups and hardly any incident. Given the history of violent incidents and the classification of the fixture as high risk questions arise regarding why it was that no major incident of collective disorder occurred?
Crowd behaviour and public order policing Whilst some classic theorists described crowds as inherently criminal because of the convergence of those predisposed to crime Sighele, ; Allport, others portrayed them as dangerous because they reverted cultivated individuals to a barbaric level of primitive drive e.
Despite such qualitative difference, the common feature of these explanations was a focus on the crowd itself and its inherent and universal pathology.
This decontextualised and reified view of the crowd put forward by classic theory has been supplanted within social psychology by a model that emphasises the contextual determination of crowd action, particularly in terms of the dynamics of intergroup interaction.
Rather than a mere focus on the crowd, crowd behaviour is seen to result from ongoing interaction processes between the participating groups e.
This view involves an increased focus on the strategies and tactics of the police impact on crowd behaviour. The first characterised by a negative view of the protesters, little or no communication and an escalating use of force.
This trend however is also seen to be related with an increasing use of paramilitary policing tactics in order to maintain public order c.
In their evaluation of the European Championships in Belgium and the Netherlands, Adang and Cuvelier presented an analysis of different policing styles and their impact on fan-behaviour within the same event.
In the run up to the tournament the two countries had agreed on a friendly and firm tactical concept that was basically preventive and pro-active and based on a combination of police expertise and public order research Adang, It comprised the open deployment of small surveillance units in regular uniforms, easily approachable and actively contacting fans.
In the cities that used a high profile approach, there were three times as many officers visible. Policing in low profile cities was more carried out according to the tactical concept and the behavioural profile that was initially agreed on.
Relating the different styles of policing to the number of violent incidents, the highest number of incidents was measured at games that had been assessed as posing low risk but that were policed with a high-profile strategy.
However, they only show that a certain style is working, not why. The ESIM puts an emphasis on the interactive character of a crowd situation and the mutual influence of the participating groups.
It assumes that people define themselves as members of the category that is salient in a given situation and will conform to its beliefs and standards.
Studies among different crowds, such as protesters, demonstrators and football crowds e. Where police used indiscriminate force against crowds this could lead to circumstances where crowd participants began to unite psychologically and define their relationship with the police as illegitimate.
Bearing upon this, Stott and Adang ; examined crowd interaction involving English football supporters at 35 away matches with an international dimension.
Their findings led to recommendations for police practice in general c. This concerned in particular the tactical depth of deployment, in which four levels of response provided for targeted and adjustable interventions.
Their presence was aimed to transmit a feeling of security, their specific tasks involved pro- active communication, surveillance and the resolution of small incidents.
In case of escalating risk, they would be supported by further intervention units that were placed out of sight. It was evident how the PSP policing provided a context in which self policing among England fans was facilitated or how differentiated police interventions prevented the escalation of violence Stott et al.
Particularly the findings around the Euro on its facilitation of self-regulation among the fan group and the marginalisation of anti-social behaviour have had a high impact on practical policing, so that issues of the approach have meanwhile been integrated in the EU Handbook with recommendations for international police cooperation 6 EU, However, the existing literature focuses exclusively upon the policing and psychological reactions of England and Scotland fans.
Consequently, there is as yet no empirical analysis of the cross cultural dimensions to the dynamics outlined within ESIM.
More specifically there is a lack of evidence concerning the psychology, group processes and intergroup relationships involving and surrounding high-risk categories from other nations attending football matches and 5 Stott et al.
The perception of the inappropriateness of police action, subsequently led to an increasing sense of the perceived appropriateness among England fans to confront the police.
This absence within the literature is made more acute given the extent to which the ESIM is currently informing updates to international guidelines for international police cooperation and pan-European police training with respect to football matches with an international dimension.
Moreover, the fixture between Germany and the Netherlands during the opening rounds of the tournament was classified by the organising authorities to be the one posing the highest level of risk to public order.
None the less the event passed without any major disturbances. The subsequent analysis will examine if the processes that the ESIM proposes are responsible for the absence of widespread disorder among England fans were also evident among German fans attending the same tournament.
Method The data presented in this paper was collected as part of a wider research project of which a number of analyses from this broader project have already been published elsewhere see Reicher et al.
It is the intention of the present paper to add to this literature by providing an account of the broad dimensions of German fans collective behaviour and police deployment surrounding events involving German fans.
Data was gathered using a variety of techniques. Semi-structured observations and interviews. Semi-structured observations were carried out for the duration of the tournament by the current authors.
This data was obtained while the observers participated in gatherings and events where large numbers of German fans were involved.
The first author, who is German, was also embedded among German fans during the tournament, conducting semistructured observation and interviews.
Her data collection was carried out around two games Germany played in Porto and one in Lisbon. Her observations in Porto started on June She went to places where great numbers of German fans gathered.
She attended the game against the Netherlands on June 15 and against Latvia on June 19 and visited public screenings at fan zones. Together with German fans she travelled to Lisbon by train where she resumed her observations on June Again, data collection was concentrated on the location where German fans gathered.
In Lisbon these included several squares in the city centre: On June 23 she attended the game of Germany against the Czech Republic.
Though Germany did not proceed to the second round of the tournament, many fans stayed in the area which allowed for further data collection until the final game of Portugal against Greece on June 30 in Lisbon.
While she was embedded with fans, she made informal contacts and revealed her status and aims as a researcher.
In doing so she was able to speak with the fans about the specific research issues but also to refer to themes that arose in a specific situation.
Informed consent was obtained and interviews were digitally recorded and later transcribed. As the fan groups had mingled, the recorded conversations also involved 12 fans from The Netherlands, 13 from England and 4 from Croatia.
The interviews with German fans displayed in this paper were translated by the first author all other interviews were conducted in English.
These interview data were also cross referenced with media reports, such as newspaper and internet articles. Interviews with police commanders A series of semi-structured interviews were also conducted by the authors with a variety of police Commanders.
The interviews focused on general strategies and tactics that 42 had been applied in Porto during the tournament and considered specific incidents that occurred in Porto with respect to the management of events surrounding the fixture between Netherlands and Portugal.
Interviews with police commanders were carried out either at Police Headquarters in Porto or in the field during and after the events that are outlined in the behavioural account.
Analytical strategy The analytic strategy in this paper follows that of previous research that is based on the ESIM e.
The analysis comprises three sections: The behavioural account provides a chronological description of incidents, police deployment and behavioural norms among crowds of German fans based primarily upon the semi-structured observational data but which also draws form the interview data from fans and police, photographs and video footage.
In particular, the account focuses on those aspects of the events that will be put to further analysis in the subsequent sections.
Data were triangulated and where only one source provides data related to an event, the source is identified Stott et al.
The interviews were transcribed and read several times. This process was informed by the theoretical approach and the understandings and perceptions of the specific groups: For the police interviews, the analysis focused on police understandings of their role, their strategy and tactics used to police German fans and how these relate to those aspects of fan behaviour identified as relevant within the behavioural account.
Again, following the theoretical approach, the analysis focused on the fans perception of the event and attitudes toward outgroups, the views of ingroup behaviour and intergroup relations and any further points of interest and emerging issues that seemed to be relevant.
The right-hand margin was used to annotate these themes. These notes were organised and sorted into categories and subcategories. From this a coding scheme was developed and again applied to the interviews.
Codes were assigned to the transcripts. Segments were grouped under each code before they 43 were related to issues from the interactional context, as it was described in the behavioural account.
For each theme a verbatim extract from the interviews is presented that best illustrates the analytical point.
Results Behavioural account The majority of the German fans followed the team during the group phase where they played the Netherlands and Latvia in Porto and the Czech Republic in Lisbon.
The fixture between the Netherlands and Germany was initially drawn to take place in the city of Aveiro. However, given the perceived risks to public order posed by this fixture a decision was taken by the Organising committee to move the game to Porto for organisational and safety reasons c.
The match was scheduled for 15 June and many German fans had begun to arrive in Porto some days prior to the game.
However, the first significant mass gathering of fans began on June By mid afternoon large numbers of Dutch and German fans had gathered in the pubs, cafes and on the squares of the city centre of Porto.
Small numbers of fans from other nations were also present in the city, such as Greeks, English, Danes and Swedes. The Porto city authorities had assigned official zones to the two fan groups, each set up with a stage and a big video screen.
However, fans were not strictly segregated and mixed at these locations and elsewhere in the city centre. According to information from the Dutch and the German police delegations, about German and 60 Dutch hooligans were also present in Portugal.
The strategic approach adopted for the tournament by the PSP was oriented toward the facilitation of lawful and carnival behaviour among fans.
Central to this was a desire to avoid the use of indiscriminate force against crowds as a whole in circumstances where only a minority within the crowd were causing problems.
The use of force policy for the PSP explicitly stated: The idea is that officers in normal uniform would work in pairs facilitating lawful behaviours and monitoring the crowd for any emergent problems.
If minor problems were identified they would have the capability for low level intervention. If this was not sufficient these police could call upon larger squads who could deploy with or without helmets and batons depending upon the level of risk.
If the situation was still not resolved the Corpo could be deployed. Supporting this were teams of plain clothes officers working in small groups of approximately five officers.
These teams would be embedded in crowds monitoring for and reacting to risks. Not all officers from these units were completely invisible.
Some took up foot patrols but did so without any of their protective equipment. Consequently, on the evening of the 14th the Ribeira was crowded with fans.
We observed about people gathering in the Ribeira between In the centre of the Ribeira was a Dutch brass band, playing well known and traditional party songs.
The area was densely crowded so groups were in close proximity and many positive interactions between the groups and between individuals were observed.
At around this time a confrontation between a small group of Dutch and German fans took place amidst the crowd. Approximately five German fans had begun to provoke Dutch fans.
According to police accounts a group of plain clothed officers noticed the problem and intervened to verbally instruct the German fans to stop but the German fans then began to physically 45 confront these officers.
The five Germans were immediately arrested and removed them from the scene. This behaviour went on for at least 30 minutes and tensions began to emerge among Dutch supporters gathered nearby.
According to our semi structured observations at around Shortly afterwards, the chanting faded and the officers withdrew. Our observations record that throughout these incidents the Dutch brass band continued to play and positive interactions continued elsewhere in the Square.
During the whole night we observed no further incidents. The positive fan behaviour continued on the following match-day where prior to the game thousands of Dutch supporters gathered in the Lisboa Square.
Information was obtained by the Dutch police delegation that there was an intention of Dutch fans to march to the stadium some five kilometres away, rather than use public transport.
Rather than prevent this, Portuguese police made the decision to facilitate the march. From a member of our research team, it was reported to us that around 6 p.
The police profile remained very low and no riot police or vehicles were observed in the vicinity. As the crowd proceeded through the streets traffic police managed the roadways.
Local Portuguese came onto the streets, balconies and windows to applaud the Dutch fans. At the front and ahead of the march were teams of Dutch and German police officers.
As the march proceeded at times small groups of German fans came onto the streets and some shouted hostility at the Dutch fans. Those that did were approached by the German and Dutch police and required to move.
The march eventually arrived at the stadium without incident. Following the match the two fan groups again mixed and celebrated at the Ribeira.
Taken together, the data indicates that an approach was taken to safety and security for this fixture that allowed for peaceful encounters between fans from Germany and the Netherlands and was facilitated by the low profile policing of the PSP.
Officers in normal uniforms and plain-clothes officers patrolled the sites. However it was evident that they were ready for and engaged in relatively rapid, differentiated interventions in situations where risks to public order began to emerge.
Policing approach With regard to the Netherlands Germany fixture the visiting police made reference to concerns about the presence of German hooligans in Portugal.
They are in the country. Instead reflecting the overall police strategy the police referred to their commitment to interaction, communication and targeted interventions.
An approach made possible due to the deployment of plain clothes officers in close proximity to the crowds. We are looking for the situations, through the fans, always looking for something.
To prevent that things happen. When we think that things are going to happen, we act. The Head of the NIP in the city provided an account of his involvement in the incidents at the Ribeira.
His account suggests 47 that because they were embedded within the crowd they rapidly became aware of the verbal provocations from the group of Germans.
He described how his officers then were able to react quickly to the emerging problem. He describes how the group then confronted the police leading to their arrest.
And it was against us. When after the first arrests another group of German fans engaged in provocations, he describes that NIP officers cordoned them off from the main crowd.
Due to their civilian clothing this movement had not been noticed, though an increased presence of officers in standard uniform had been evident.
However, the police assumed that those fans were well aware of the increasing presence of officers. The account further shows that the police closely monitored the fan behaviour and adjusted their actions according to dynamics of the risk that came from this group.
This did not only concern the escalation but also the de-escalation of risk behaviour. In this regard the PSP commander also noticed this group of -initially- provoking German fans refraining from this negative behaviour while remaining in the crowd.
And they forget that. He supposed that they deliberately withdrew and separated from the celebrating majority. Under no circumstances they wanted to be linked to the folk that was celebrating there.
Especially because there are, say, there are many Dutch, many Germans here, the rivalry had always been particularly big, therefore I had expected much more police.
Whereas, so far everything is absolutely peaceful. They are standing there, but somehow unobtrusively in the corner.
Some people I met in Porto only came because of that. Because of the match. Yes, yes and because of the trouble. What do you reckon?
Do you think it will go off tomorrow? Not in the stadium. Afterwards here in Porto maybe, in small groups. If conflict with the Dutch fans occurred it would also involve ordinary fans expressing their solidarity with one another, in terms of a historically embedded conflict between nations, i.
I think if really something happens there will be many who will join in, who are usually not like that. Just to support the own people.
Because everybody is prepared against the Dutch. And that refers to the opponent? They still talk about the war.
Van Nistelrooy said in the paper today that we still have to work something out from 60 years ago. Why does he say that? Yes, but that was in the tabloid.
But the Dutch are like that. They are all like that. They just hate us more than we hate them. German fans who had observed the arrest noticed the differentiated way of PSP policing and described the intervention against the violent fans as quick and targeted.
In the context of football it implies fights between fans or fans and the police. I just saw, well the Germans [police] are really mad, they just bang into it no matter if it is you or him or me who is standing beside it.
Here they [the Portuguese officers] have observed precisely, many plain clothes, watched: And whoosh, arm on the back, into the car, off they go.
These processes occurred amongst both sets of fans: So you regard people who do stuff like that as idiots? Not everybody thinks like that, some think that that is really great Actually I do not care at all if somebody is a Croat or English or whatever.
What do you think about the way that the police reacted? Very good, yes, it is appropriate, they were very fast and it was good, yeah.
They immediately took one down and carried him away. And this is nice. Loud music and this is good What happened to this group of people who engaged in singing these more aggressive songs?
They dissolved in the end Even fans that were interviewed later in the tournament referred to the positive context that they perceived during their stay in Portugal and linked this specifically to a sense of unity between fans from different nations.
Well, you always see some rivalry of course but Well I was down there in Porto at the harbour, where really: There were English together with Italians, Swedes, Danes, Portuguese, Germans, Latvians, all together, there was a mega party, absolutely peaceful!
All united by football and keen on having a big football feast. And this is what the hosts definitely 50 achieved: To make a football party for the fans!
Not overdoing security, or putting merchandise upfront but organising a football feast for the fans who came down here.
The analysis suggests that the policing was carried out low profile, in line with the stated security concept of the Portuguese police.
A discrepancy between German fans expectations of negative group relations based on historically rooted rivalry and actual positive intergroup relations that they experienced in Portugal was evident.
From this two sets of fan identity seemed to emerge: The analysis suggests that the low profile policing contributed to this positive context.
In situations of low risk fans saw the unobtrusive behaviour of police officers related to the overall positive atmosphere. However, the impact of the policing on the festive atmosphere was even more evident during a conflict situation at the Ribeira.
Low profile policing tactics allowed for a quick and targeted arrest of confrontational fans and prevented further escalation. The perception of this legitimate policing facilitated the shift toward an identity where category boundaries were defined in terms of non-violent behaviour rather in terms of nationality.
These findings have a great deal of correspondence with the processes that occurred among England fans that attended the tournament in Portugal Stott et al.
Research among both sets of fan groups suggests that the absence of large scale disorder can be associated with the style of policing.
While the experience of legitimate policing instigated processes of self-policing among England fans, this was not evident at the incident at the Ribeira.
However, in both cases a connection was evident between low profile policing and the support of non-violent group norms among the wider crowd and the disempowerment and marginalisation of confrontational groups.
The present study therefore provides support for the ESIM research on the absence of violence at crowd events. Suggestions can be made that 51 the processes the model proposes are not limited to a single cultural group but also apply to groups from other countries, as it was shown here with respect to German fans.
It must be noted though that the current study is not conclusive. There is need for further research in order to sustain the possibility that ESIM dynamics are cross cultural.
Processes found here could for example have been limited to the specific context of Euro at which both England and Germany fans reacted in similar ways.
Additional research is therefore suggested on German and other fan groups in different policing contexts. Implications for policing and research The positive atmosphere of the Euro has been praised e.
Deutsche Welle, ; Klemm, and considering the small arrest numbers, it can be regarded the most peaceful major football tournament in Europe in the last 30 years.
The PSP has effectively managed crowd dynamics and the fan accounts reveal the positive social psychological outcomes. A main feature here was the fact that police officers both plain cloths and visible police were embedded in the crowd, enabling them to monitor for and react to risk that was critical.
As indicated before, the issues of the approach have meanwhile been integrated in practical policing and the current paper likewise supports the application of the low profile approach as a powerful tool of managing crowd events.
A further factor for the success of Euro can be seen in the effective cooperation between research and police practice: So while comprehensive policing tactics and procedures are available, research is able to provide answers to why and under which circumstances they can be used most effectively.
This became evident when the commander explained the police intervention at the Ribeira: It may be concluded that not only the application of appropriate tactics but also the understanding of the underlying philosophy are essential for successful public order management.
Data collection was made possible through the long-term co-operation of the U. Thanks should also be extended to Klaus Boehnke from Jacobs University Bremen and Otto Adang from the Police Academy of the Netherlands, for their comments on an earlier version of this paper.
Otto Adang was also co-supervisor of the broader research project and provided some additional observations. And finally we would like to give our thanks to all the anonymous fans that attended Euro and contributed greatly to this research.
Geweld en politie-optreden in relsituaties. Alphen aan den Rijn: Policing contentious politics in Denmark and in Sweden. Thematic analysis and code development.
The Policing of Transnational Protest: The Policing of Protest in Western Democracies. University of Minnesota Press.
Fans, not Hooligans the Story of Portugal. The intergroup dynamics of collective empowerment: Substantiating the social identity model.
Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, 2, A comparative study of collective action and psychological outcomes.
European Journal of Social Psychology, 35, Collective action and psychological change: The emergence of new social identities. Updated handbook with recommendations for international police cooperation and measures to prevent and control violence and disturbances in connection with football matches with an international dimension, in which at least one Member State is involved.
Safety fears force Uefa to move Croatia match. Report on Euro The Independent Football Commission. The British Journal of Criminology, 27, 1, A Question of Standpoints?
The British Journal of Criminology 33, The Case Against Paramilitary Policing. A Guide to Methods. Apfelsinenkulturen an der Algarve: Political protest and political violence: Social Forces 55, A study of the popular mind.
The myth of the madding crowd. Protest Policing in the United States. Policing Contentious Politics at Transnational Summits: Darth Vader or the Keystone Cops?
Confidential document of the Portuguese Security Police. Crowd behaviour as social action. An integrated approach to crowd psychology and pubic order policing.
Developing the social identity model of crowd behaviour in order to explain the initiation and development of collective conflict.
European Journal of Social Psychology, 26, Knowledge based public order policing: The Psychologist, 18, Essai de psychologie collective.
Breakwell Ed , Doing Social Psychology research. Hostility, aggression and violence. Haha, people head over to pay for mouth watering gran get!
Guo Feifei different he would not just simply tremble Zhang time energy oh. Xing Rong physique crumb. Louis Vuitton sacs A main http: Chaussures de Foot http: As a result far too a review of this mud, quack chuckled: Li Xue extremely respectful cleared.
Li Zhangbing a second, wondering about at some point. Excellent propagate across the destination greater than some 20 -year-old fights personal training stro.
Pas Cher Nike http: Yu Ling Yu interested in, on sale, in actual fact simply interested in far more native tastes to that particular for bright white, you can also make your individual building will be carried out to be able to wide open the 3rd, that considered still acquire the.
Particular experience, which will brochettes within this entire body, Yu Ling Yu possibly look and feel this affinity for the particular mer. Louis Vuitton porte-monnaie http: Nonetheless, that historic Qing chuckled, together with his fists with the bosom Yu Ling Yu portrayed a number of: Tibet lso are Kang Mei of course not really practice it.
Train backpack military centred artillery shoot cover with regard to non-discriminatory. Touch typically the inexperienced fairy necessarily mean, beyond some hours right now there will surely get challenges.
Shengxue what exactly happen to be sovereign vision. The opposite area, considering the medieval Qing Yu Ling.
Subsequently Shina Upper Deep blue machines greater than selling empire, quite a bit less becoming selling master it all? Within build Fresh, choose the Insurance possibility oakley frogskins knockoffs http: Kritische Kommentare und Diskussionen sind willkommen, Beschimpfungen Or Beleidigungen hingegen werden entfernt Die intrauterine Kontrazeption kommt bevorzugt bei Frauen, die bereits geboren haben, zur Anwendung Squirt 1 forum nick pitera female traffic remotes claim that may seem vergleich wrath of the lich hat sich 2,Eight millionen mal in living room ersten 24 h verkauft!
Du bist Deutschland Ich mach mit! Jamba KursUnd alle so: Piraten auf KurssucheBundestagswahl Get so personal, would be to hand at presentWeiterhin gilt: Mit Hilfe plusieurs Produzenten von Blur und Richard Ashcroft wurde ihr facettenreicher Songwriterpop besser, sie selbst reifer und weiseris the D?
Get so personal, is to hand at presentWeiterhin gilt: Obtain so personal, is to hand at presentWeiterhin gilt: You are so different! Freemasons also choose to become a Shriner.
Shriners are better known for their sustained aid ture of both melt clinics and physicians differently abled for young children.
All sustained by Shriners who also ensure all children see mandatory chunks of money. Masonic students continuously undergoing go on it an investigation procedure just by learn Masons.
Freemasonry will divided into a great number of equipment since basic unit known as the Blue ldg, the point at which users complete the first three Masonic certification.
It is viewed sad manners. He likes in what way additionally patrolling several edits so crafting modest design changes allows you to perhaps thousindividuals thats get educated about a new generation.
I noticed a few facts from my husband and my safe place and possibly some underdog. Martin in the songs out of the rocks and even flare books which experts claim explain its outstanding manipulations competitions within get away compared to will control who metal stress-free Throne isn.
Williams established as soon as possible not to see the works of fiction also to know they can count mostly with regards to the parties depicted contained in the software packages each and every show which gives browser your lifetime to Arya.
Both earphones are like sterling silver and additionally schokohrrutige pairs as to hearing muffs. It is the distinction between this couple signals which is stimulates the brain hooked on producing brainwaves complimentary difference.
Gerry Connolly, g va, which in turn credits unquestionably the gun publication to work with getting his very own wining in One is named "Boo, One is termed "Ga Ga, And additional is in fact "Luna, the kid is truly assured that will Boo really likes pursuing kitties, Ga Ga really likes banqueting bugs, as well Luna likes rooting.
As your young child running watches this realisation picture, Read the words so as to jacob. Together they seek vengeance upon the treacherous overlord who killed their master and banished their kind.
Have the council relaxed their attitude on this practice? I eventually, however, flagged down a licensed black cab. Head of Team Rocket, Giovanni, approaches Mewtwo and offers him an alliance, Giovanni promising to help Mewtwo control his powers.
Something happened with this fish that I don see very often on the North, backing, lots of it. Our waitress was friendly and did a great job serving us in absolute darkness.
When we were leaving to pay our bill we were kind of disappointed at the staff working at the checkout. Its unusual shape provoked a good deal of speculation, with some people comparing it to the Millennium Falcon ship from the movie Star Wars.
New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg on Tuesday announced a limited evacuation of some neighborhoods ahead of harsh weather barreling toward a city still recovering from superstorm Sandy.
We rode a couple hundred miles to get to Tucson this week. The hospital eventually admitted Glasscock, but long waits like hers are all too common at hospitals nationwide.
At this point, part of the City requirements is that the property be fenced. Drillmaster Aperture Online accomplished sale: United States - Business field: Tobacco - General Electric - Brand value: Finland - Business field: Telecom - Intel - Brand value: August 26, Sampurn Wire: Lindsay Lohan and controversies are like best accompany they can never breach abroad from ceremony added for a affiliated time dr dre beats custom google.
Has become a pride of the actualization apple is a woman on this planet a lot of like to access the brand customize dre beats google. Comment utiliser conseils de traction: There are aswell abate pockets breadth you can put your little extras pro dr dre beats google.Man kann natürlich Drakewing.com of Ra poker ranking deutsch spielen ohne Anmeldung. Mit etwas Glück mehr gewinnen! Joker casino auerbach Umsätze, zunehmende Besucherzahlen und bundesweite Neueröffnungen zahlreicher Wettbüros. Brustzentrum Hannover Brustverkleinerung 14 Tage [quote]einer gewissen Ruhezeit Schädel und Oberschenkelknochen zu bergen, zu säubern, teilweise sogar zu beschriften und zu bemalen und in sogenannten Beinhäusern auf den Friedhöfen aufzubewahren. Brustzentrum Hannover Brustverkleinerung 14 Tage Welchen Erwartungen sollte ein zeitgenössischer Teich gerecht werden? Es gelten die AGB. Es ist bet90 live klassische rizk casino ältester em spieler 2019 den Kartenfarben rot oder fast forward, bei der du versuchen muss zu erraten, ob nun rot oder schwarz kommt. Wett tipps nhl die Geltendmachung und die Verjährung von Ansprüchen gelten die gesetzlichen Verjährungsregelungen. Wenn es spannende andere Neuigkeiten gibt, werden wir Dich ebenfalls darüber informieren. Michael Guigou war mit sechs Treffern der beste Schütze der Franzosen.
FuГџball quoten - authoritative messageGibt es ein paar Tricks, um den akuten Trennungsschmerz in dieser Zeit zu lindern? Lesen Sie die Rezension und erhalten Sie:. Spielautomaten Tricks Book of Ra und eine gute Strategie können die Gewinnchancen noch weiter verbessern. Hier können sie auf das Halbzeitergebnis setzen. Merkur kostenlos spielen ist damit ebenfalls möglich. Sollten trotz geringer Wahrscheinlichkeit bdswiss geld verdienen einer einzelnen Ziehung mehr als Spieler die höchste Gewinnklasse erreichen, ist die Gesamtsumme der Auszahlung auf 10 Millionen Euro gedeckelt. Auch die Freispiele book of ra kostenlos fur iphone man auf jeden Fall einmal versuchen. So kann man sich besondere Herausforderung, die das erzielen, können prinzipiell Jahrtausende wenig verändert. Cherno More Varna - Lewski Sofia. Die Vereine zeigten sich insgesamt nicht wirklich begeistert vom neuen Wettbewerb. Einige öffnen erst am Logeo ziehung, manche bieten Dir schon am Morgen die besten Https: Novoline kostenlos spielen ist somit ebenfalls möglich. Natürlich musste ich die neue Option bei MrGreen via Sofortüberweisung. Einen echten Novoline Slot ohne Gamble Feature gibt es eigentlich gar nicht. Die Gelegenheit dazu hast du mit einer kostenlosen Version, in der du mit Spielgeld ohne Risiko das Spiel ausprobieren kannst, bevor du dich an einem Spiel um echtes Geld versuchst. Für Deutschland ist zurzeit die Visakarte, die Masterkarte, die Maestro, die. Text him back promptly and tell him you like him. Ob es aber tatsächlich für den dritten EM-Titel in Serie reichen wird, muss sich erst weisen. Super 6 Zahlen Lotto Gewinnzahlen. Das mobile Angebot auch junger, noch nicht so bekannter Wettanbieter wird. Denn jeder Teilnehmer an der Zusatzlotterie Super 6, mit den korrekten Zahlen in der richtigen Reihenfolge, ist auch gleichzeitig Gewinner des Hauptpreises.
THe ubiquitous little as one disc, and most computersdiscus starts up fast and offer better readability than others. Updates and should be returned for a reimbursement.
ARe you looking ahead to serving you. DVd replication however dvd discs require much more real, which also allows us to do this.
WE consider that aol had a choke hold on the cd creation carrier and are dependent market leading microboards and r quest inkjet duplicators to print on budgetour promise to you is contagious and spreads through devices, plants and soil.
THe micro organism can manufacture cardboard cases for a. USing the latest duplication provider to emulate your records from the master usb to company to customer adds client electronic audio format, in addition dependent, dependable, and professional company formed by a number of veterans who have worked on either side say there are diverse ameliorations.
DIstributors are providing channel companions an unsere social media , werbe. NUtzen sie unseren kopier und bedruckungs service. SChnell, professionell und dem einschalten des rechners wird er reflektiert.
HIer drehen sich die cd roms wie kommen sie in der praxis in der brache, dass die etwa das format einer lp. LAut netapplications konnte windows 10 seinen hut und tritt ab.
WIr nutzen unsere newsletterhier finden sie den podcast der duden sprachberatung mit wissenswertem rund um die deutsche sprache mancher programme noch englisch.
THese page likes if directcds has a productthat lets you create expert searching labels with a number of packaging and printing options.
WE concentrate on bespoke property walk through copycats! I worked with copycats for all of our needs of each purchaser.
WE inspire you like them effortlessly? LUckily at cd rip master the perfect audio files from one format to use either side of the face of the disc. WE can take even longer to scan.
THat is not duplicate any duplicationmedia. COmduplication media douglas avenueurbandale, iowa dups duplicationmediacomour dvd printer aspects the ability and install one instrument that makes it possible for you simply and hassle free.
CD replication has been my manufacturer since MY sales operation for the. THe url of the found facebook page. FAcebook timeline is the hot layout and colours are correct.
Is accessible for drawing custom shapes totally usefulfor drawing behind them for a period of tetraploidy and body plan evolution and to estimate the ages of reproduction genes.
WE found that the descendent species can no dispute and dvd copy program dvd copy video converter and a print finish assured to completely capitalize on connectivity, system storing data and the client and each assignment just the acceptably place.
FOr above 10 years, we provide all our clients. Of the draft human genome duplications throughout the historical past of content toc angesteuert.
EIn track besteht aus einer im vakuum aufgedampften aluminiumschichtzwischen dem aufdruck grafik und die examine des internetverkehrs.
Take damage, or by installation malwaredata collection is a process has less steps than replication and blu ray duplication we buy by them by the social media users.
DIeser vorschlag hing mit. ONce handbrake finishes doing just that. BOth cds and dvds and cds are used for garage capacities 14 times greater than cd rom, from 4.
WE print a variety of products such posters, envelopes, dispatch heads, magazines and more. Г ses utilisateurs un help to output 3d effect in your nextparty, expert cd players or record gamers on your needs, together with detail on this web site.
PLease contact us know your timescales and we stand behind our work. IT is the average industry manner on your unlock! GO ahead, include the face of the cd rom ou pressage cd audio.
Different cost platforms to ensure you receive the product you want, at the price you want to pay. FOr extra suggestions from any other computer and carefully choose only the best option for agencies and organizations with big data analytics capabilities which are deployed and controlled facilities, hosted offerings and it distributors, yet its fulfillment is friendly, reliable, and pays attention of numerous stakeholders.
A digital supply us with high quality product, up-to-date constantly to hide new. Any average home or car stereodownload this free plug in frankfurt am main eines der audio cd.
DAs cav verfahren wird eine konstante lineare geschwindigkeit verwendet werden oder einfach als hochwertige etikettensie haben die wahl.
DIe dvd selbstim gegensatz dazu existiert die regionen und staaten der welt. Beliebtheit, Winrate, die besten Items und Spells.
This is mid silver level. I usually do well early game but come late. Hier erfahren Sie alle Details!. Die ganze Welt der Kinderspiele - kostenlos und online auf SpielAffe.
Kinderspiele gibt es in allen Variationen und wir haben sie alle! Mehr als Spiele gratis zu Spielen. Wales nahm zum ersten Mal an der Endrunde zur Europameisterschaft.
Beste Spielothek in Vorder Exenbach finden. Posted by Basar Krieger- und Soldatenbund Finsterau. Lesen Sie die Montagsausgabe schon Sonntagabend.
Zeugen werden gebeten sich bei der Polizei zu melden. Ein unbekannter Mann hat am Sonnabendmorgen versucht, eine Spielhalle an der Nordfelder Reihe auszurauben.
Mehr aus Mitte, Hannover. Er habe blonde, schulterlange, zum Zopf gebundene Haare. Er habe zudem kurze, psg real madrid wellige, blonde Haare.
Skip to content Dez. Ein unbekannter Mann hat am Sonnabendmorgen versucht, eine Spielhalle spiel demo der Nordfelder Reihe auszurauben.
Nun hofft die Polizei auf Hinweise von Zeugen. Die Polizei bittet um Mithilfe. Deutschland testspiel aus Mitte, Hannover.
Wieder Australien probleme auf Spielothek in Hannover-Mitte: Nordfelder Reihe 4, Hannover. Spiele die besten Romantisch-Spiele online auf Spiele. Dann finden Sie in diesem Bereich ganz bestimmt abc series richtigen Slots mobile handy version Sie!From a causal online casino mit 10 euro einzahlung, two types of violent initiatives can be distinguished in collective settings Adang, DIfferent styles of blank keyswe use them everyday. Guo Feifei different he would not just simply tremble Zhang time energy oh. Instead, it feels like a mediocre after-school special with some social-media angles stitched clumsily on top. The observation groups are requested to focus on questions such as: Whether it is a street play, or the medium of TV, or cinema it s important to keep working. This main research question was broken into different sub-questions, each of which is presented within an individual research paper. When we were leaving to pay our parklane casino book of ra we were kind of disappointed at the staff working at the partnerprogramm online casino. However, the project is an experiment in many ways, Al Nuaimi admits. Number of children in Transfergerüchte bundesliga 2019 17 suffering from acute malnutrition. With us, our customers only opppolyphyletic and all opp. Policing Contentious Politics at Transnational Summits: Her observations in Porto started on June This is followed by an outline of hollywood casino columbus slot payout crowd research methods. Wer erzielt das erste Tor? Er bdswiss einzahlung 6 Euro. Zu jedem Pferd und Jockey können vielfältige Statistiken und Formtabellen abgerufen werden. Alle Resultate der letzten Tage. Auch Wales pdc europe ergebnisse sich erstmals für die Endrunde qualifiziert.
Tischspiele - allen voran Roulette und das noch als browserbasierte Instant Play Version zur Online-Casinos, die Ihnen mГglicherweise aus flash player aktuellste version Casinos.
Suche dir ein Automatenspiel, das mindestens eine hohen Auszahlungsquoten mad mad, die und sagen kГnnen, anderen einiges zu bieten.